The Federal High Court in Abuja has dismissed a legal challenge to the emergence of former Kogi State Governor, Yahaya Bello, as the All Progressives Congress (APC) candidate for Kogi Central Senatorial District in the 2027 general elections.
Justice Inyang Ekwo, who delivered the judgment on Thursday, ruled that the plaintiff, Momoh Yusuf Obaro, failed to follow the party’s prescribed procedures for resolving disputes before taking the matter to court.
Obaro had approached the court, claiming that he won the APC senatorial primary held on May 18, 2026, and asking it to recognise him as the legitimate candidate for the district.
In the suit marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1085/2026, he challenged Bello’s emergence as the party’s flag bearer.
However, Justice Ekwo held that the plaintiff failed to establish that he exhausted the internal appeal mechanisms provided for in the APC constitution.
The judge explained that although Obaro submitted a petition to the party’s Appeal Committee, he failed to demonstrate that he subsequently appealed to the National Working Committee (NWC), as required by the party’s rules.
Citing Paragraph 15(3) of the APC constitution, the court maintained that members dissatisfied with the outcome of party primaries must first seek redress through the Appeal Committee and the NWC before resorting to litigation.
Justice Ekwo consequently ruled that Obaro's decision to institute the action without completing the prescribed process invalidated his case.
“By rushing straight to court without approaching the NWC, the Plaintiff bypassed a mandatory condition precedent. Consequently, I resolve this issue in favour of the 1st Defendant (INEC) and the 2nd Defendant (Yahaya Bello),” the judge declared.
The court also rejected the documents tendered by Obaro in support of his claim to have won the primary, questioning their authenticity and evidential value.
Justice Ekwo noted that the documents were not signed by the chairman or secretary of the electoral committee that conducted the exercise.
He described them as documents of dubious origin, stressing that unsigned documents could not be relied upon as credible evidence in establishing the plaintiff's claim.
The judge further faulted Obaro for failing to seek legal advice before presenting the documents to the court, suggesting that those who provided them might have misled him.
“Take it that the Plaintiff is not a lawyer, but he should have taken a step to consult his lawyer before dumping these documents on the court. These unsigned documents submitted by the Plaintiff are of dubious origin,” he said.
“In law, an unsigned document is of no value. The documents are of dubious origin,” Ekwo added.
The court further observed that Obaro had agreed, in documents submitted during his membership and nomination processes, to comply with the APC's internal dispute resolution framework.
Justice Ekwo held that having undertaken to abide by the party's constitution, the plaintiff could not bypass its established procedures and seek judicial intervention prematurely.
The judge subsequently dismissed the suit for lacking merit and ordered that each party bear its own costs.
Reacting to the judgment, counsel to Bello, Paul Daudu, SAN, welcomed the decision, describing it as a sound pronouncement that upheld the rule of law and the democratic process.
Daudu maintained that Bello's victory at the primary was based on the overwhelming support of APC members and that the court's decision had affirmed the legitimacy of his client's emergence.
He also described Obaro's case as an attempt to obtain through litigation what he had failed to secure at the party primary.
“We commend the learned trial Judge for his erudite and painstaking judgment, which has upheld the sanctity of the law and the democratic process.
“The dismissal of this suit comes as no surprise, as the plaintiff merely embarked on a speculative voyage—seeking from the bench a victory he failed to secure from the electorate.
“Our candidate’s triumph at the primary election was the product of an overwhelming endorsement by the people, and we are gratified that the court has given judicial validation to that clear mandate,” Daudu said.

Leave a Reply